Strategy factory scorecard

Run 2026-11-15 13:20 · 477 Nifty 500 stocks + Nifty and Bank Nifty · data 2011-01-03 to 2026-11-13 · 65 versions of 32 strategies.

How to read this. Each strategy was tuned and judged only on the training period (2012-2022). The proof period (2023-today) was never used for picking, so it shows how the pick did on unseen data. PROMISING = beat Nifty after costs in both periods with an acceptable fall, and most settings of the idea worked (robust). FRAGILE = passed, but only some settings worked. Stocks: today's Nifty 500 list is used for all years, so stocks that collapsed and left the index are missing: real results will be lower. Futures: index prices used as a proxy, 1x (no leverage), no margin interest.

Best version of each strategy

VerdictStrategyBest settingsTraining yearly return (Nifty)Training worst fallProof yearly return (Nifty)Proof worst fallTrades train / proofWin %Profit factorSettings that beat Nifty
PROMISINGMomentum rotation 12-1
Each month hold the stocks with the best 12-month return (skipping the last month)
top 20 + cash when Nifty < 200-day22.7% (13.2%)-25.0%36.4% (8.7%)-18.4%698 / 24655%2.87100%
PROMISINGVolatility-adjusted momentum
NSE Momentum-index style: best 6 and 12-month return per unit of risk
top 20 monthly + Nifty filter17.8% (13.2%)-21.6%28.9% (8.7%)-15.8%289 / 27661%3.9375%
PROMISINGWeinstein stage 2
Breakout above a rising 30-week avg on 2x volume; sell on a weekly close below it
30-week19.0% (13.2%)-22.7%43.2% (8.7%)-25.3%89 / 5039%4.19100%
FAILED PROOFDonchian breakout
Buy a new 100-day high; sell on a new 50-day low (Turtle style)
100-day22.8% (13.2%)-34.4%37.7% (8.7%)-38.6%186 / 9424%2.0567%
FAILED TRAININGMA crossover
Buy when 20-day avg crosses above 50-day avg; sell on cross back down
20/5013.8% (13.2%)-19.3%13.2% (8.7%)-11.1%262 / 12843%2.1633%
FAILED TRAINING52-week high breakout
Buy a close above the 52-week closing high on above-average volume; 3-ATR trailing stop
volume 1.5x4.6% (13.2%)-18.2%16.7% (8.7%)-15.5%259 / 20640%1.480%
FAILED TRAININGLow-volatility momentum
Best 12-1 month momentum among the calmer half of stocks
top 20 monthly13.0% (13.2%)-36.3%23.2% (8.7%)-24.4%320 / 32167%3.290%
FAILED TRAININGO'Neil breakout
Leader near 52-week high breaking a 35-day base on 1.5x volume, Nifty uptrend
CAN SLIM (price only)6.7% (13.2%)-25.0%23.5% (8.7%)-26.1%334 / 24538%1.280%
FAILED TRAININGNear 52-week high
Hold the stocks closest to their 52-week high
top 20 monthly13.1% (13.2%)-28.9%14.6% (8.7%)-20.3%673 / 75258%2.090%
FAILED TRAININGLow volatility
Hold the calmest stocks (lowest 1-year volatility), reshuffle quarterly
top 20 quarterly9.2% (13.2%)-24.6%9.5% (8.7%)-14.7%116 / 6962%3.820%
FAILED TRAININGRSI(14) pullback
Buy an oversold pullback while the 50-day avg is above the 200-day; sell when RSI tops 70
RSI14<405.7% (13.2%)-38.9%12.8% (8.7%)-24.3%480 / 30738%1.220%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: Turn of month
Long for the last 2 and first 3 trading days of each month
long only4.4% (13.2%)-38.7%6.6% (8.7%)-13.5%132 / 4754%1.410%
FAILED TRAININGSupertrend
Buy when Supertrend turns up above the 200-day avg; sell when it turns down
14,311.3% (13.2%)-22.1%9.4% (8.7%)-23.0%218 / 14643%2.390%
FAILED TRAININGADX trend
Buy when +DI crosses above -DI with a strong trend (ADX); sell on reverse cross
ADX>255.8% (13.2%)-19.0%8.9% (8.7%)-22.3%801 / 36736%1.280%
FAILED TRAININGIBS reversion
Buy a close near the day's low after a down week in an uptrend; sell on a close above yesterday's high
IBS<0.13.1% (13.2%)-32.4%9.5% (8.7%)-24.4%1444 / 118160%1.100%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: Turn of month
Long for the last 2 and first 3 trading days of each month
long only6.0% (13.2%)-26.0%4.4% (8.7%)-12.6%132 / 4761%1.820%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: Trend filter
Long while above the 200-day avg, otherwise no position
long or flat9.5% (13.2%)-23.8%3.8% (8.7%)-14.1%39 / 1423%2.970%
FAILED TRAININGNR7 breakout
Buy a breakout above the narrowest-range day of the last 7; 2-ATR trailing stop
NR7-0.2% (13.2%)-45.6%7.8% (8.7%)-33.7%1135 / 47637%0.990%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: Trend filter
Long while above the 200-day avg, otherwise no position
long or flat5.0% (13.2%)-27.8%4.2% (8.7%)-18.6%57 / 1126%2.160%
FAILED TRAININGMinervini trend template
Stage-2 uptrend, tight range, breakout above 20-day high on 1.5x volume
VCP breakout5.6% (13.2%)-26.2%7.2% (8.7%)-33.6%388 / 32533%1.220%
FAILED TRAININGRSI(2) pullback
Buy a sharp 1-2 day dip in an uptrend; sell when price closes above its 5-day avg
RSI2<59.9% (13.2%)-21.8%4.3% (8.7%)-26.4%1479 / 115269%1.440%
FAILED TRAININGInside-bar breakout
Buy a breakout above an inside day in an uptrend; 2-ATR trailing stop
inside bar2.0% (13.2%)-40.6%4.8% (8.7%)-29.7%1098 / 47739%1.050%
FAILED TRAININGMACD trend
Buy a MACD cross up above zero in an uptrend; sell on cross down
MACD + Nifty filter3.2% (13.2%)-16.5%4.2% (8.7%)-27.6%654 / 43235%1.220%
FAILED TRAININGBollinger reversion
Buy a close below the lower Bollinger band in an uptrend; sell at the 20-day avg
2.5 std2.9% (13.2%)-23.8%2.9% (8.7%)-20.4%429 / 37359%1.230%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: MA crossover
Long when 20-day avg is above 50-day avg, else short
20/50 long/short2.9% (13.2%)-45.0%2.9% (8.7%)-27.2%53 / 1840%1.600%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: RSI(2) reversion
Buy dips above the 200-day avg, short spikes below it; exit at the 5-day avg
long/short1.6% (13.2%)-12.8%-0.1% (8.7%)-8.4%132 / 4560%1.340%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: Donchian
Long on a new 55-day high, short on a new 55-day low (always in)
55-day long/short0.0% (13.2%)-36.2%-0.5% (8.7%)-19.0%25 / 1024%1.330%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: RSI(2) reversion
Buy dips above the 200-day avg, short spikes below it; exit at the 5-day avg
long/short-3.3% (13.2%)-46.2%-1.4% (8.7%)-15.4%129 / 3963%0.880%
FAILED TRAININGNifty futures: Supertrend
Long when Supertrend is up, short when down
10,3 long/short2.4% (13.2%)-35.4%-7.1% (8.7%)-47.2%90 / 3940%1.390%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: Donchian
Long on a new 20-day high, short on a new 20-day low (always in)
20-day long/short4.0% (13.2%)-46.9%-5.6% (8.7%)-36.6%62 / 2348%1.560%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: MA crossover
Long when 20-day avg is above 50-day avg, else short
20/50 long/short9.1% (13.2%)-44.9%-9.6% (8.7%)-36.1%53 / 2455%2.000%
FAILED TRAININGBank Nifty futures: Supertrend
Long when Supertrend is up, short when down
10,3 long/short3.2% (13.2%)-44.4%-14.0% (8.7%)-52.0%88 / 3545%1.390%

All versions tested

StrategySettingsTrain returnTrain fallTrain tradesTrain PFProof returnProof fallProof trades
52-week high breakoutvolume 1.5x4.6%-18.2%2591.4816.7%-15.5%206
52-week high breakoutvolume 1.0x4.7%-19.5%2731.4415.1%-16.7%220
52-week high breakoutvolume 2.0x3.3%-17.7%2481.3820.6%-10.7%205
ADX trendADX>255.8%-19.0%8011.288.9%-22.3%367
ADX trendADX>208.5%-33.2%9181.349.8%-27.1%404
ADX trendADX>301.6%-24.3%5411.085.5%-19.0%278
Bank Nifty futures: Donchian20-day long/short4.0%-46.9%621.56-5.6%-36.6%23
Bank Nifty futures: Donchian55-day long/short-7.3%-65.1%290.88-8.7%-32.4%12
Bank Nifty futures: MA crossover20/50 long/short9.1%-44.9%532.00-9.6%-36.1%24
Bank Nifty futures: MA crossover50/200 long/short-4.2%-61.5%191.17-1.8%-26.7%5
Bank Nifty futures: RSI(2) reversionlong/short-3.3%-46.2%1290.88-1.4%-15.4%39
Bank Nifty futures: Supertrend10,3 long/short3.2%-44.4%881.39-14.0%-52.0%35
Bank Nifty futures: Trend filterlong or flat9.5%-23.8%392.973.8%-14.1%14
Bank Nifty futures: Turn of monthlong only4.4%-38.7%1321.416.6%-13.5%47
Bollinger reversion2.5 std2.9%-23.8%4291.232.9%-20.4%373
Bollinger reversion2.0 std1.9%-25.2%6161.097.2%-13.2%501
Donchian breakout100-day22.8%-34.4%1862.0537.7%-38.6%94
Donchian breakout55-day19.2%-32.2%3251.7555.0%-28.1%139
Donchian breakout100-day + Nifty filter19.7%-33.5%1682.3636.5%-35.1%74
Donchian breakout55-day + Nifty filter15.2%-30.4%2961.7562.7%-21.5%104
Donchian breakout20-day + Nifty filter13.0%-37.0%5281.5119.3%-30.2%199
Donchian breakout20-day10.5%-40.6%6391.3120.4%-35.3%280
IBS reversionIBS<0.13.1%-32.4%14441.109.5%-24.4%1181
IBS reversionIBS<0.21.4%-38.3%18771.039.1%-26.5%1278
Inside-bar breakoutinside bar2.0%-40.6%10981.054.8%-29.7%477
Low volatilitytop 20 quarterly9.2%-24.6%1163.829.5%-14.7%69
Low volatilitytop 30 quarterly7.4%-23.9%1373.988.4%-13.3%76
Low-volatility momentumtop 20 monthly13.0%-36.3%3203.2923.2%-24.4%321
MA crossover20/5013.8%-19.3%2622.1613.2%-11.1%128
MA crossover20/50 + Nifty filter13.2%-22.8%2431.8220.1%-13.6%98
MA crossover10/3012.4%-31.1%5261.7114.6%-17.0%217
MA crossover10/30 + Nifty filter8.4%-32.0%4451.5522.3%-15.0%147
MA crossover50/2002.7%-26.1%771.3719.4%-21.6%42
MA crossover50/200 + Nifty filter2.5%-34.5%581.1017.8%-12.0%30
MACD trendMACD + Nifty filter3.2%-16.5%6541.224.2%-27.6%432
MACD trendMACD2.6%-18.8%8051.153.3%-34.7%592
Minervini trend templateVCP breakout5.6%-26.2%3881.227.2%-33.6%325
Momentum rotation 12-1top 20 + cash when Nifty < 200-day22.7%-25.0%6982.8736.4%-18.4%246
Momentum rotation 12-1top 10 + cash when Nifty < 200-day26.4%-31.8%3892.6939.4%-18.4%120
Momentum rotation 12-1top 2028.7%-36.1%7612.9652.1%-34.7%286
Momentum rotation 12-1top 1031.6%-46.0%4312.4565.6%-33.1%142
NR7 breakoutNR7-0.2%-45.6%11350.997.8%-33.7%476
Near 52-week hightop 20 monthly13.1%-28.9%6732.0914.6%-20.3%752
Nifty futures: Donchian55-day long/short0.0%-36.2%251.33-0.5%-19.0%10
Nifty futures: Donchian20-day long/short-2.1%-40.1%721.06-5.3%-36.5%25
Nifty futures: MA crossover20/50 long/short2.9%-45.0%531.602.9%-27.2%18
Nifty futures: MA crossover50/200 long/short-5.1%-66.3%170.83-1.3%-27.8%5
Nifty futures: RSI(2) reversionlong/short1.6%-12.8%1321.34-0.1%-8.4%45
Nifty futures: Supertrend10,3 long/short2.4%-35.4%901.39-7.1%-47.2%39
Nifty futures: Trend filterlong or flat5.0%-27.8%572.164.2%-18.6%11
Nifty futures: Turn of monthlong only6.0%-26.0%1321.824.4%-12.6%47
O'Neil breakoutCAN SLIM (price only)6.7%-25.0%3341.2823.5%-26.1%245
RSI(14) pullbackRSI14<405.7%-38.9%4801.2212.8%-24.3%307
RSI(14) pullbackRSI14<354.8%-33.3%3831.2317.7%-16.8%285
RSI(2) pullbackRSI2<59.9%-21.8%14791.444.3%-26.4%1152
RSI(2) pullbackRSI2<156.7%-21.2%19181.226.4%-23.9%1309
RSI(2) pullbackRSI2<105.6%-23.4%17351.199.9%-19.2%1252
Supertrend14,311.3%-22.1%2182.399.4%-23.0%146
Supertrend10,37.2%-22.5%2401.569.9%-18.0%150
Supertrend10,25.2%-21.5%4171.354.3%-18.9%261
Volatility-adjusted momentumtop 20 monthly + Nifty filter17.8%-21.6%2893.9328.9%-15.8%276
Volatility-adjusted momentumtop 20 monthly19.7%-36.3%2903.3145.2%-31.8%322
Volatility-adjusted momentumtop 20 every 6 months17.3%-36.3%925.9235.8%-36.2%120
Volatility-adjusted momentumtop 20 every 6 months + Nifty filter11.6%-36.2%895.4937.2%-18.4%99
Weinstein stage 230-week19.0%-22.7%894.1943.2%-25.3%50

Download all results (Excel / Google Sheets) · Home

Past results do not guarantee future returns. Next step: the PROMISING strategies go to paper trading.